I've always been a defender of Vader, but I do think he is a bit weak. I've pretty much agreed with the path's to victory views expressed in the thread. I do think that you CANNOT overlook the fear factor that ATE brings to the deck. This is partly why I always inform new opponents of the card before we play. It was intended to be known that it is in the deck, and I think it should be known that you should always try to defend against Vader.

I do think there is quite a bit of strategic planning with Vader, but I think two tweaks are required to make his deck strength right about where it should have been.

I think Dark Side Drain should be a 4 and that YSANC should discard power combats. I think that pretty much solves any strength issues for the deck, while still making him playable.